I’ve been doing a lot of research on this Kony 2012 thing. A little disclaimer
before I begin… This post is NOT about whether or not what is happening in
Uganda is right or wrong. This post is NOT about whether or not the US should do
something to help. This post is about the purpose of the video and nothing more.
Please do not attack me or reply with your stand on the issue. I am not taking a
stand with this post.
So moving on...
As I watched the video I
couldn't help but realize the manner in which the film was edited and produced.
The process is often referred to as "emotional porn". The touching moments where
the child web chatted with her grandparents, the birth of the guy's son, the
happy moments with his son; all of those things had absolutely nothing to do
with what the video was really about. Or did they? The purpose of these scenes
was to elicit an emotional response from the viewer. To get the viewer to
identify personally and emotionally with the people who feel passionately about
this issue. Thus making the viewer feel that the way these people feel is right.
Okay, so that's not necessarily a bad thing. If people feel passionately about
the issue they will be more inclined to help. Great…right? If you’re helping the
right people…then yes.
However, I cannot seem to find any solidified
proof that donations will truly go toward helping these “invisible children”.
The manner in which the video was made makes me nervous. The level at which it
attacks the human psyche suggests desperation; an appropriate emotion given this
situation. Or it could suggest manipulation. After intensive research I have yet
to find any reputable charitable organization that backs up this organization
Invisible Children Incorporated. Charity Navigator gives this organization a low
two star rating for accountability (Charity Navigator, 2012). You can look at
the data here,
http://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=search.summary&orgid=12429. Be
sure to look at the revenue to expenses comparison in recent years.
When
you click on the links below the video to help the first thing you see is a
place to send donations. The only information I could find about where the money
is going was provided by Invisible Children, Incorporated. Financial records have indicated that approximately 32% actually goes directly towards their cause. So where is the
rest going? We are not sure yet if this video and organization are reputable.
This video also claims that it serves the purpose of increasing
awareness so that the US Government will become involved and help. The US
government has sent 100 special operations forces commandos to help train the
Ugandan Defense Forces who are hunting down Kony and the LRA (Baldauf, 2012).
Special operations forces are the best of the best. This is the best we have to
offer. The United States government is fully aware of the situation with the LRA
and has already taken extraordinary measures to aid the victims. In fact, in
2008, USAID support for northern Uganda totaled an estimated $138 million
(USAID, 2012). Funny, the viral video didn’t mention that.
Based on my
research, I’ve come to the conclusion that this video is most likely an
exploitation of a very terrible situation for personal financial gain.
Please feel free to do your own research as well. I've listed my references below.
Baldauf, S. (2012, March 7). Lord's resistance army: After long silence,
the us-tracked rebels attack. Retrieved from
http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Keep-Calm/2012/0307/Lord-s-Resistance-Army-After-long-silence-the-US-tracked-rebels-attack
Charity
Navigator. (2012). Invisible children. Retrieved from
http://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=search.summary&orgid=12429
Garcia, L. (2012, March 8). Kony 2012: scam. Retrieved from
http://www.coscampusonline.com/2012/03/08/kony-2012-scam/
On kony 2012.
(2012, March 7). Retrieved from http://thedailywh.at/?s=Invisible Children, Inc.
USAID. (2012, January 9). Uganda overview. Retrieved from
http://www.usaid.gov/locations/sub-saharan_africa/countries/uganda/
No comments:
Post a Comment